Dr. Edelstein was kind enough to share this thought provoking op-ed piece by Adam Grant from the New York times
“Can We End the Meditation Madness?”
“I AM being stalked by meditation evangelists,” Grant writes.
“They approach with the fervor of a football fan attacking a keg at a tailgate party. ‘Which method of meditation do you use?’ . . .”
Read the full article here => Meditation Madness and then return here to see my response and learn how all of this relates to CBT-REBT.
Thanks to Michael for sharing this article. The author raises a lot of interesting points, but it is hardly within the scope of my reply to address every aspect It is even becoming a bit unwieldily focusing on the few issues that grab my attention.
First of all, I have read recently that from the beginning, the founders or popularizers of the modern mindfulness movement such as Jon Kabat-Zinn were very aware that if mindfulness “took off,” some people would seriously misrepresent it and exploit it in various ways. “Mindfulness Evangelists” as the author, Mr. Grant, refers to them, are annoying no matter which wagon they hitch their star to this week, and it would be unfortunate to rely on them for meaningful insight into the nature and value of mindfulness. Yet, that is what Mr. Grant seems to base his article on. If you are rooting for mindfulness meditation and mindful living to have an expanded role in society, this fad phenomenon can be regarded as ultimately helpful or unhelpful, even embarrassing. Time will tell, I suppose, and will depend somewhat on how many influential people have reactions similar to Mr. Grant. Nonetheless, a few issues which surround this discussion are important to consider:
1. Mindfulness meditation is hardly a fad. It has had a 5,000 year history in Asia in the form of Vipasana meditation in the Buddhist tradition. Zazen, Zen seated meditation, a relative new kid on the block compared to Vipasana, is an important variation, and is very similar, especially in the beginning. The modern, secular form of mindfulness meditation as introduced by John Kabat-Zinn and others has been around for about 35 years. No responsible proponent of mindfulness (or any other school of meditation for that matter) regards it as some kind of panacea nor endorses the over-reaching claims of the “evangelists,” nor believes that it is “good for what ails ya,” nor believes that everyone can or could or should practice. Those are the things that Mr. Grant attributes to the claims of the evangelists, but such claims are not in my opinion rational or responsible.
2. Dr. Ellis and other pioneers, probably including Dr. Edelstein, are not fans of meditation, lumping it together with hypnosis, relaxation and various somatic approaches, regarding it as merely palliative. Dr. Ellis, always pragmatic and multi-modal, often said that he recommended some of these approaches to clients, but he clearly was not a fan, and his “pragmatism” comes across as just a little bit arrogant and condescending. Still, while all forms of meditation overlap in some important ways, that are not all alike, and mindfulness meditation is not palliative, not by design, intention, nor in effect. For emphasis, let me repeat, mindfulness meditation is not palliative, not by design, intention, nor in effect. Just the opposite. Mindfulness meditation teaches awareness of and more importantly, acceptance of cognitive-emotional-physical experience, and teaches th e ability to have our experiences without reacting to them, that is without drawing conclusions or making judgments, which means without awfulizing, self-downing, “musterbating,” or other distortions and negative self-talk that people use to upset themselves. It is because of this distinction that mindfulness practices and mindfulness meditation have been becoming integrated into various schools of CBT almost from the beginning, much to some people’s surprise, as well as becoming integral to the newer, “Third Wave” schools of behaviorism such as ACT and others.. Gary Emery (“Rapid Relief from Emotional Distress…”), part of the team that developed Cognitive Therapy with Beck, et al at the University of Pennsylvania Medical School in the 1970’s, very early on had a sense that “Acceptance” (note the upper case “A”) was an important part of CBT. I have called Acceptance the “soft underbelly of REBT” because after all that disputing an d disputing and disputing, what you are left with is simply what is. After you thoroughly dispute “A must not be A!” what you are left with is “A is A” That’s Acceptance, Baby!
We can only wonder how Dr. Ellis might have regarded this if the timing had been different, and if he had had the leisure and the opportunity to give mindfulness a better looksee.
3. Mr. Grant discusses mostly in the framework of “stress reduction” and indeed mindfulness is often presented in that context. Even John Kabat-Zinn framed his approach as MBSR or Mindfulness-based Stress Reduction. However, personally, I see this a bit of slight-of-hand and misdirection. “Stress” is an external, an “activating event” in REBT terms, usually time-related, typically describes a situation in which we have too many tasks, too many competing, conflicting priorities, impossible deadlines and not enough time to complete everything that needs completing. It can also involve difficult personal relationships and noisy or chaotic or otherwise unhelpful environments. Without relief, people react with anxiety, irritability, depression, physical symptoms such as tension headaches, reduced performance and self-defeating compensation such as drinking or drugging. Certainly m indfulness and other types of meditation can be an important tool in resolving stress. However, it is only one tool in what should be a comprehensive strategy which specifically addresses the situation and the needs of the individual. On the other hand, sometimes stress is situational, and “all” one needs to do is give up a stressful job and replace it with a less stressful one. Poof! No more stress! Well, maybe. Clearly, unarguably there are lots of ways to reduce stress that don’t involve meditation, as Mr. Grant points out. But I think this misses the point just a little.
4. Â It misses the point and I think Mr. Grant tips his hand when he says “I have nothing against it [meditation]. I just happen to find it dreadfully boring.” Â Not just plain, old vanilla boring, mind you, but DREADFULLY boring. Â However, a stern wrap on the knuckles for playing Â games with the language in that way! Â Meditation is meditation is meditation. Â It is neither inherently boring or not boring. Â What Mr. Grant is saying that he has found himself dreadfully bored when he has attempted it. Â We don’t know how many attempts or how often or what type(s) of meditation or under what circumstances. Â Be that as it may, Mr. Grant seems to be saying that he cannot sit quietly for a few minutes without becoming dreadfully bored. Is that important? Â Well, we don’t know exactly what it means for Mr. Grant, but it is hardly an uncommon reaction, and in my observation, it is a symptom of modernity in which many or Â most people seem to have a touch of ADHD, the exhausting running like a chicken with our heads cut off disease; Â multitasking, inattentive, distracted, rushed and harried, unable to be still for even a few minutes, head in the (digital) clouds, no longer well-connected to society or to one another, or even to immediate experience of being alive as previous generations were naturally. Â Of course this is stressful, BIG TIME stressful. Â However, Â I don’t think the primary problem is one of stress, Â but is rather one of ATTENTION, or the lack thereof. Â Along with just doing it, that is, Â just paying attention or “attending”, Â disciplining oneself to slow down and learning to take care of our breathing are intrinsic to the process, both on the meditation cushion and during our routine activities as much as we can Â and to the extent that we can.
The fact that Mr. Grant is dreadfully bored is at least “interesting,” as mindfulness meditation was not designed to be stimulating and “entertaining” in the way that Grant and other may expect it to be. Â Stimulation and entertainment are Â far from the point. Â Mindfulness meditation provides an opportunity to practice, to stop for a few minutes, to slow down, to pay attention to our breathing, and notice how our thinking, emoting and physical sensing often operates like the proverbial monkey cage full of agitated monkeys, screeching, jumping all over the place, making “monkeyshines,” Â rattling the cage bars. Â If you can appreciate this metaphor, then you (or Mr Grant) hardly need a zen master to sell you on the benefits of attention training. Â If one cannot or does not see the value in Â that, then I think it is safe to say that meditation is not for them.
Bottom line, I see mindfulness more as a matter of attention training than stress reduction, and there are various techniques and approaches that can help us with this Â as an enhancement to or as distinct from Â formal mindfulness meditation such as
Rex Alexander and REBT Info are participants in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com.
Help REBT Info continue to serve you. We get a small commission from Amazon.com or other
concerns when you purchase items using the links on these pages. Thank you for your support! ~Rex
TOS / Terms of Service
Pretty basic stuff: No fussing, no fighting, no cussing, no spamming, no scamming, no blaming, no flaming, no hating, no bating, no trolling, no personal attacks. No pornography (Damn!). The Golden Rule applies. Focus on issues, ideas and principles rather than on personalities and you will fit right in. Please keep your contributions friendly and polite, treat your fellow members and readers with respect and all will be well.
All content and information submitted become the property of REBT Info (REBTinfo.com)
We at REBT Info value your privacy. Your personal information is secure with us. Secure server software (SSL) encrypts all information you enter before it is sent to us, and all of the customer data we collect is protected against unauthorized access.
We WILL NOT sell, rent, distribute or otherwise share your personal information, including e-mail address, to or with anyone for any reason (except in the extremely rare, unlikely case of demands by duly authorized law enforcement acting strictly in accord with due process).
All rights reserved. The content of this website or any portion thereof may not be reproduced or used in any manner whatsoever
without the express written permission of the publisher except for the use of brief quotations in a book review.
This website is for educational, informational and entertainment purposes only. By accessing this blog you understand and agree to these conditions, as well as to the other Terms of Service / TOS posted, and which may be updated and amended from time-to-time.
By accessing this website blog and related media, you affirm that you have read, understand and agree to our Terms of Service / TOS which may be updated and amended from time-to-time.
This is a public blog
Anything you post may be viewed by the public. Therefore, do not post anything you wish to remain private.